The apelin receptor generates increasing interest as a potential target across several cardiovascular indications. However, the short half-life of its cognate ligands, the apelin peptides, is a limiting factor for pharmacological use. In this study, we systematically explored each position of apelin-13 to find the best position to cyclize the peptide, with the goal to improve its stability while optimizing its binding affinity and signaling profile. Macrocyclic analogues showed a remarkably higher stability in rat plasma (half-life >3 h versus 24 min for Pyr-apelin-13), accompanied by improved affinity (analogue 15, Ki 0.15 nM and t1/2 6.8 h). Several compounds displayed higher inotropic effects ex vivo in the Langendorff isolated heart model in rats (analogues 13 and 15, maximum response at 0.003 nM versus 0.03 nM of apelin-13). In conclusion, this study provides stable and active compounds to better characterize the pharmacology of the apelinergic system.